It’s not even noon yet and I’ve already had an adventure today. This is how it started:
I got up this morning, checked my e-mail, backed up my files, had a shower, and got dressed (my usual ritual). I kissed the wife and went off to work while she returned to bed for an hour. She had a doctor’s appointment today and got to sleep in a bit. I drove to work, talked to my boss about the new tourism website, went back to my desk, and found a voice mail waiting for me. It was Kathryn. I called her back and she told me the ceiling was leaking. Where? I asked. Your office, she said. *insert expletive*, I said. How bad is it? Well… she said, your keyboard got wet, along with the keyboard, the computer itself, oh, and your new external hard drive. *insert another expletive*, I said. Okay, I’m coming home.
So, with my boss’s blessing and good wishes, I drove back home after a whopping one hour of work. Kathryn had cleaned up the damage by the time I arrived and placed a big plastic tarp over my desk. The leak had stopped, but some writing papers had gotten soaked, and there was some plaster stains on my desk. Fortunately, the water didn’t get near any of the outlets, and after testing my computer, monitor, scanner, etc., I determined that everything was working fine (the mouse was a bit funky for a few minutes, but it seems to be okay now).
Part of my testing included checking to see if the cable modem was damaged. So I opened Firefox and my Outlook, checked my e-mail, and everything seemed okay. I noticed there was e-mail from Timothy Manning, editor of Black Ink Horror. I had been corresponding with him over the weekend. I was planning to post about this once the full story was out, and the message he sent me this morning was a perfect denouement for such a lousy morning.
To bring you up to speed, here’s a bit from his first e-mail:
Many thanks for submitting "Wood" to BLACK INK HORROR, and sorry for the long wait. We have almost filled our first three issues, and I’ve really been deliberating on which stories should fill those final spots.
The story was very well written throughout, and I found the concept to be unique and interesting. I enjoyed how you broke the main narrative up with the fable, and how you allowed the horror to simmer under the tale’s surface. The tale drips with atmosphere and mood, and your characters came across as intriguing and interesting. I flew through the tale in anticipation of how both stories would come together. Unfortunately, I felt that the ending was a little too vague for my tastes. I’ve read the story twice now, and I’m still left with with more questions than I’m comfortable with. Don’t get me wrong; I love stories that challenge me to think. I just really expected some killer twist at the end, and instead I was left scratching my head a bit. "Wood" came very close, but unfortunately, I’ve decided to pass on it.
The above comments represent only my opinion, and reflect more personal tastes than fact-based criticism. As I really enjoyed the tale, I do hope that you submit another.
Probably one of the nicest rejection letters I ever received (he also congratulated me on my sale to Cemetery Dance, a feat which has impressed more people than I ever would have expected). Funnily enough, this was one of the very few stories to which I had written an alternate ending. I had opted for the vaguer, more ambiguous ending because I felt it was more unsettling. I mentioned this to the editor in my reply, saying that if that was the only thing keeping him from accepting the story, maybe he would like to read what I called the "Writer’s Cut."
He wrote me back the right away:
To tell you the truth, I’ve been agonizing over your story for about a week. I love stories with elusive, though-invoking endings that leave something to the reader’s imagination, and my first thought when finishing "Wood" was "wow, that was creepy. Now I have to read it again and figure it out." After reading it for the second time, I couldn’t determine if the ending was to vague, or if I was too thick to get it.
I would love the opportunity to read the other version; please send it along. I’ll certainly consider the story again. There’s a good chance that I’ll read the "Big Reveal" and think, "oh, man–how did I miss that?". If that’s the case, I’d likely choose to run the original. Either way, I’ll finally know what happened!
The plot thickens.
So, I sent off the other version of the story, telling the editor that I understood there was no guarantee he would like this version (much less accept it), and that I was just glad he wanted to read it and, as he said, find out what happened.
That was on Saturday. I never heard back from him that day, or on Sunday. I figured he was either a) waiting until later to read it, or b) had already read it, still didn’t like it, but was trying to find a nice way to break it to me. He needn’t have worried, of course. I knew that was a possibility, and I had pretty much written it off. I was already thinking about what story I was going to send him next.
Then, after my Waterworld adventure this morning, I received the following e-mail:
Thanks so much for taking the time to send this along, and no apologies needed for the prattling! I’m glad that you were willing to patronize me by sending the other version over. This reading marks the third time I’ve read "Wood", and it was just as creepy this time around. I can certainly understand why it unsettles your wife.
To put your mind at ease, I would love to run the story. It’s the type of tale that gets under your skin and sticks with you long after you’ve finished reading it. I think that was why it took me so long to decide on it, and why I was second guessing myself mere seconds after pushing the "send" button on that first rejection. The "Writer’s Version" did clear up the confusion, and I was excited to see that I was apparently correct in my interpretation of the ending. Of course, now I’m debating on which version I should run. I think that I’m still partial to the original ending, although I might recommend importing a sentence or two from the "Writer’s Version".
Again, thanks so much for working with me on this. I’m actually quite relieved now that I got the call right the second time around!
No, thank you, Mr. Manning. You brought some much-needed good news to what was shaping up to be a lousy, waterlogged day.
Anyway, that’s my story about the acceptance of "Wood" and the water damage in my office. It could have happened in any other room, but of course it had to pick the one with all the books and computer equipment. Fortunately everything appears to be in good shape, and, even better, I’ve got another story coming out.
"Wood" will appeared in issue #2 of Black Ink Horror, due out in April 2007.
Now I should probably go finish blowdrying my story notes.
Update (4:27 p.m.): Tim just sent me the payment for my story, roughly six hours after he accepted it, which makes it the fastest turnaround I’ve ever experienced. Payment on acceptance rules! Booya!
- Currently reading: The Road, by Cormac McCarthy