The other day I mentioned to a friend at work that I was planning to see Kill Bill – Vol. 2 (good flick, worth checking it out — not that it needs my hype), and she told me that some kids in school are being negatively affected by the violence in the film — specifically that the slang verb Uma, as in to go Uma on someone, is being used in reference to girlfight antics on the schoolyard.
This story reminded me of another I had read about some time ago. This one was about a young woman who was killed because her car ran out of fuel while she was driving home. She had carried a gas can to a nearby service station, filled it up, and had started back when she was set upon by a group of black youths who took the can, doused her with gas, and lit her on fire. When they were finally caught and asked why they had committed such a horrendous act, the youths replied they had gotten the idea from an ABC Movie of the Week — Fuzz, an adaptation of one of Ed McBain’s 87th Precinct books.
That event took place in the late 1960s or early 1970s, I don’t recall which, and it successfully put an end to TV violence at that time. And while there is little doubt that the youths were telling the truth about where they got the idea to burn the girl alive, I think the real question is, had the movie not been aired, would they have let her pass unharmed, or would they have simply attacked her in some other grisly, perhaps less-creative, fashion?
In the film Bowling for Columbine, a father of one of the deceased kids is at a rally comparing the malefic influence of Marilyn Manson music and Doom-style videogames to commercials run on television to sell automobiles. At the end of his rant he says (and I’m paraphrasing): "Not everyone who watches a Toyota commercial goes out and buys a car — but some people do!" The crowd, assumably made up of other likeminded individuals who believe the medium is not only the message but also the murderer, explode into applause.
The truth is that millions of teenagers play videogames like Doom, millions of teens listen to albums by Marilyn Manson and his ilk — and 99.99% of these kids do not kill each other. Doom and Marilyn Manson are certainly not the only things to have been blamed in the wake of the Columbine High massacre, but they’re certainly on top of the bereaved parents’ shit-list. In their grief — which must certainly be great — they seem to have forgotten that the vast majority of the kids who have played Doom or listened to the dulcet tones of Marilyn Manson have not taken shotguns to school and killed their classmates. So far as we know, Harris and Klebold are the pioneers of that particular territory. Which begs the question, are the millions of kids who have partaken of Doom and Manson in actuality walking timebombs destined to explode in some horrible way, or were Harris and Klebold merely a couple of fucked-up kids who perhaps should have been watched a little more closely by their parents — parents who claimed they didn’t have the foggiest idea that their sons had turned their garages into pipe-bomb labs and ad-hoc armories. Perhaps I’m being too hard on their familes, who are surely social pariahs wherever they go now, but I don’t think I’m being any harder than they and their kind have been on pop culture and the entertainment industry.
I think in the end what needs to be remembered is that these are all mediums of entertainment, and none of them are meant to be taken very seriously. Sure, some critics and professors will strive to cite the importance of books, movies, and music in society, but it doesn’t change the fact that the majority of people who buy books, watch movies, and listen to music do so for pleasurable purposes rather than academic ones.
In the case of people old enough to be prosecuted in a court of law and committed to
one of the countries finer correctional institutes, the responsibility is clearly their own, and most people are not inclined to argue that particular point. But for kids not yet old enough to vote, there seems to be an inherent knee-jerk reaction to blame the book, the movie, the music, or the video game. But even though the subject may be younger, the simple truths of reality remain the same; the blame simply falls upon the accused’s parents or guardian. Yes, it is their fault. And you want to know why? Because of those millions of other children who have been exposed to the same mediums and are not executing their classmates gangland-style.
After all, when the Manson Family killed Sharon Tate and wrote "HELTER SKELTER" on the wall, you didn’t see anyone trying to ban the Beatles’ White album.
Ian